I've seen several posts recently where genealogists and family historians have encountered vitriol from readers and attendees at lectures. It comes from people who simply shut down and stop listening at the mere mention of AI (meaning they also shut down to any other potentially useful information being provided). Some people argue it should not be a part of genealogy. They shun the very idea of AI. I personally encountered this when I first started blogging about using AI to help me with my routine genealogy tasks. I received comments telling me I was wrong to embrace it. AI was going to destroy the environment. And a few even said as soon as they realized a post was about AI they stopped reading. I briefly took to including a "trigger warning" for those who felt so strongly. Rather than have them attack me after reading a post, I hoped they'd quietly move on. But then I stopped to think about why they felt so strongly, and I stopped adding those trigger warnings.
While there are certainly valid and logical arguments to be made against the use of AI (everyone is absolutely entitled to their opinion), I wonder how much of the reaction comes from uncertainty. How will AI be used? Who decides where to draw the line? But uncertainty doesn't mean we should lock, stock and barrel toss anything out the window.
Of all the arguments against it, the environmental effects are the ones I personally feel are the most justified. Data centers can use a great deal of electricity, and some also use substantial amounts of water for cooling. How much water they use depends in part on the cooling system. In the short term, neither of these is cause for celebration. But I suspect, as time marches on, data centers may become more efficient. Will they ever be a "non-issue"? I don't know. But I strongly suspect things will get better—especially with all the people who, quite rightly, feel strongly and are outspoken about preserving our environment.
Artificial intelligence is scary. But history reminds us that tech makes lives better, not worse, an opinion post by Rikki Schlott, reminds us how, throughout history, our lives have improved with technology. Since the beginning of time, technology has brought about change. Creating tools for hunting, making fire, the invention of the wheel, the development of drugs commonly used to treat ailments today...all of these were technological changes. When computers were first a "thing," people were afraid of them too. They thought computers would cost people their jobs, because computers were like giant brains poised to do all the thinking. And today? Today, computers are part of everyday work in many fields. Humanity learned to coexist with machines.
Change is often scary. Change can be uncomfortable. But closedmindedness is not the solution. AI has a lot of potential. The scary part is humans control this potential (at least for now). Humans program and teach AI. Humans test AI. Humans use the output. And most importantly, humans create the guardrails. Is it really AI some fear? Or is it actually the humans behind AI?
Many genealogists and family historians are embracing AI. Every week there are new posts to show it has value and can be used as an accompaniment to traditional research. I'm fascinated by all the ways it's being used! From research plans to full-text searches to graphical depictions of data trends from a GEDCOM (check out Steve Little's Kinfolk Observatory), we are just at the beginning of how AI can and will be integrated into our research. I believe humans will always be necessary in genealogical research. The researcher still has to decide whether a misspelled name points to the relative we’ve been looking for, and whether two records belong to the same person—or to name twins. AI isn't going to replace us as researchers. Hopefully, it will make us better researchers by providing us with possibilities we might never have found on our own.
I, for one, enjoy reading about where and how AI is being implemented in the field of genealogy and DNA. Will it solve every family history conundrum? No, I don't believe it will. But I do think it will help some family historians break down their brick walls. Strictly from a data perspective, AI can help sift through large amounts of data much faster than I could by hand. At some point, this will help researchers make connections they might otherwise never have made. None of this means you have to embrace or even like AI. But it is becoming a part of our genealogical lives. For me, learning to live with AI means knowing when it can help and when I need to do the work myself.
Image by StockSnap from Pixabay

