I'm a big user of the Notes field. I use it to track extended family members of people married into my family, multiple spouses and other children I may not want to research - but I need to know who they are, and the info needs to be visible so I can properly assess new hints. And equally as important, the regular Notes field syncs to FTM, so it's the best place to add notes that need to be in both places.
Stickies essentially obliterate my view of all of this information. As you can see in the screenshot, you can't even see my Notes if I start to add one. Even in the default view, the feature takes up 1/2 of my Notes field and I now have to scroll to see all my data because Stickies are at the top of the field. To be able to see Stickies AND Notes, I'd have to scale down to less than 75% of my already small screen size, and I literally can't even read the text.
It was bad enough when they changed Quick Edit and the slider closes the Notes/Tags/Comments and they have to be reopened every time. I tried to roll with the punches on it, I know change is inevitable. But now, Stickies are compounding the problem. If we could move them to the bottom, toggle them when we want to use them...or better yet...give them their own heading like Comments, Notes and Tags!! (instead of slapping then on top of the Notes field)...it would be amazing, and potentially one of the best new recent features. But as it stands, the implementation is absolutely awful for small screens.
Introducing changes in a thoughtful and meaningful way for users is just as important as dumping a whole lot of new features onto the site. Making sure changes work for those using various types of devices is an extremely important part of website design (for all websites). If, like me, you use a small screen and find these new changes frustrating, be sure to submit feedback on Ancestry's site. Occasionally they listen and sometimes even make changes as a result of user feedback. I don't really want this feature to go away (I'm just frustrated), but it would be really nice if it had been implemented in a way not rendering a widely used field almost useless for a subset of users. How do you feel about the new feature? Have you encountered any challenges with the recent site changes?
Eeek - that's not great. There's a current discussion on the Ancestry Users group on Facebook about Stickies etc. Crista Cowan from Ancestry has been participating. If you're on FB, it might be worth posting that screenshot so she can see it as well - she often can move things up on the list of priorities when she sees concrete examples.
ReplyDeleteThis is the direct link to the group: The discussion was started on February 15: https://www.facebook.com/groups/469269581613668/
Thanks for the link! I'm going to post there when I get home from work today. Certainly can't hurt to chime in.
ReplyDeleteI also let her know as I wasn't sure you'd be on FB...Hope you don't mind.
DeleteThank you for doing that! I am on FB (and I did post) but so often comments get lost in all the back and forth of discussions. I appreciate you passing this along :)
Delete